Pieces of my Heart Game Walkthrough.
Since the puzzles are glitchy, and can take about 30 minutes to complete just one, I have compiled all of the correct responses for the text conversations, so that you can make your time worthwhile.
Preface/How to Play
This guide is solely for the conversations. The full conversations, with all of the potential rewards, is only available on the Hard difficulty; I think you can only get one prompt per puzzle on Easy, and two each on Medium. Since the pieces of the actual jigsaw puzzle are randomly shuffled every time you start, there is no real concrete guide as to how to solve them.
Olivia
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will talk about being a librarian
Answer: Tell her to prove that she is one
Reward: Her carrying a stack of books in a library
Prompt: She will then ask about what to do before a date
Answer: Simply tell her to work out, in order to calm her mind
Reward: Her jogging in a sports bra and leggings
Prompt: She will start talking about loving classic movies
Answer: Acknowledge her reference to Godfather with “Sollazzo”
Reward: Her VHS/DVD collection
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Depends on how you feel about indie movies”
Answer 2: “Great idea! Why didn’t I think about that?”
Reward: Her reclining in the theatre seat, pulling up her skirt and revealing her panties.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will start wondering about showing some skin
Answer: Tease her about wanting to show some ankles
Reward: A nice, wholesome shot of her face and cleavage
Prompt: She will then turn to ideas on what to wear to the date
Answer: Tell her that she should dress to impress
Reward: She sneaks a pic of her pulling up a skirt to reveal a little bit of her underwear
Prompt: She will then ask a riddle about who/what loves books
Answer: Simply answer “Olivia?”
Reward: Her sprawled out on the bed naked, surrounded by books
Mildred
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will lament about all of the jerks that she matches with through the app
Answer: Jokingly tell her about how you named your biceps
Reward: A zoomed-in shot of her mildly-shocked face
Prompt: She will wonder why you chose her on the app
Answer: Tell her that you want someone that can cook
Reward: A selfie next to one of the ovens at the restaurant she works at
Prompt: She will ask about your interest in books/reading
Answer: Mention your interest in crime books
Reward: She will show the books that she keeps in her purse, along with some of her cleavage
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “I take it you’re not a vegetarian.”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “I love how adventurous you are.”
Reward: X-ray through the table, showing her rubbing your crotch with her foot.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask whether or not you like being called ‘daddy’
Answer: Ask if she likes to be called ‘mommy’
Reward: A steamy shot of her on a bed, with a tease of her breasts and crotch
Prompt: She will then talk about ‘adult teasing’ you throughout the date
Answer: Tell her that you will raise her on her bet
Reward: A fully nude bust shot
Prompt: She will admit that she has one last picture, but is unsure whether or not to release it
Answer: Mock her resorting to this ‘secret weapon’
Reward: Her sprawled out on the bed, again, but fully revealed
Hope
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will complain about all of the cheesy one-liners revolving around her name
Answer: Admit that she took away your opening line
Reward?: This is actually her profile pic, again
Prompt: She will then start talking about how dates don’t have to be expensive or over-the-top
Answer: Tell that you are cool with a cheap date
Reward: Her in a bikini-style top, holding her skateboard behind her head
Prompt: She will admit that she lives a very low-budget lifestyle
Answer: Tell her that you wouldn’t judge her
Reward: A zoom-in on her face, with a pier/boardwalk in the background
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “You really like getting high”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “I’m really more of a ‘brah’ “
Reward: Her sitting on a bench, pointing at her open mouth.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will start out by addressing the fact that the app is there for a reason
Answer: Tell her that you are cool with keeping things casual
Reward: Her lifting up her sweater top, revealing her bush
Prompt: She will then continue the explicit questioning, asking about your performance
Answer: Assure her of your impressive stamina
Reward: Her sitting on a park bench, with her legs up/pants partially down
Prompt: She will tell you that she took another photo, but is somewhat embarassed by it
Answer: Tell her that you will not laugh
Reward: A playful shot of her legs and breast, done in a ‘modeling style’
Michelle
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will open with some tarot cards
Answer: Humor her and choose the left pile
Reward: Her holding the cards that she drew in front of her face to read
Prompt: She will then talk about retro games
Answer: Ask if she is a gamer
Reward: She gives a peace sign, sitting behind a box with some old school consoles in it
Prompt: She will then make a vague riddle to tease you a bit
Answer: Ask her to give you a hint
Reward: Her holding up a pair of chicken breasts, in front of her apron-covered breasts
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “It’s about to get warm in here.”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “Slow and steady, or hard and fast?”
Reward: Her lifting her leg, revealing a flour-y hand print on her back pocket.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will then give you another riddle regarding something that opens doors
Answer: Ask if it’s a buttplug
Reward: Her bent over, with a buttplug in, and underwear covering up the rest
Prompt: She will ask about your member, and why you haven’t sent an unsolicited pic of it yet
Answer: Tell her that you love the in-person reactions you get over its size
Reward: A nude, upper-body shot, showing off her admittedly small breasts
Prompt: She finally asks for your ‘best’ pick-up line
Answer: “Were those pants on sale? If they were at my house, they would be 100% off”
Reward: A nude shot of her holes, agape from the aforementioned buttplug.
Aurelie
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will start talking about her love of ballet
Answer: Talk about how impressive the dancers are
Reward: She is in a leotard, in a warm-up pose
Prompt: She will then start talking about traveling around
Answer: Ask about her doing ballet professionally
Reward: Her giving two peace signs behind the curtain of a stage
Prompt: She tells you about how her and her friends are picking out dresses for her date.
Answer: Offer to help her, and check out how she looks in the dresses
Reward: Her making a hand heart, while wearing the green dress for the date
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Just like that? No roses or candles?”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “You mean stiff, and it’s an open bar tonight.”
Reward: Her sitting on the bed, pour white wine (possibly sparkling) over her exposed breasts.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will talk about how this date is purely physical
Answer: Tell her that you only want her
Reward: Her fingering herself underneath her panties
Prompt: She will then boast about how her flexibility makes her popular among her past lovers
Answer: Assure her that this will be a night to remember
Reward: Her lifting up a leg, while wearing a green dress and panties
Prompt: She will talk about having a gift to give you
Answer: Tell her you will treasure it
Reward: Her naked on a bed.
Madison
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will come on strong and tell you that you will remember this night forever
Answer: Remind her that forever is a long time
Reward: An upward shot showing off her clothed breasts and face
Prompt: She will continue to talk about how many men are either weak or scared of her personality
Answer: Suggest that she needs someone to challenge her
Reward: Her in a nightgown, lying on her bed with a book
Prompt: She then talks about being a powerful woman, and how stressful it is
Answer: Tell her to just come down to your level for the night, and enjoy herself
Reward: A bathroom selfie, wearing nothing but a towel
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Ready to get sweaty?”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “Time to drop low and drop loads.”
Reward: Her grinding against your crotch (both still fully clothed).
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She opens up about how she already started drinking, and wondered if you can keep up
Answer: Assure her that drinking is as easy as breathing for you
Reward: A suggestive photo of her with the neck of a beer bottle in her mouth
Prompt: She then starts talking about wanting to do something sexual while on the dance floor.
Answer: Tell her that you have done the nasty in front of strangers before
Reward: Her sitting on the floor, fingering herself under her panties
Prompt: She will ask whether or not you are proud of your body, should you be stripped down
Answer: Tell her that you are proud of your member
Reward: Her lying on her bed, fully nude.
Amanda
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask if you matched with her solely based on who she is
Answer: Ask if she is famous, and that you just thought that she was cute
Reward: A promotional picture of her as a professional competitive gamer
Prompt: She will start talking about wanting to go to an arcade for the date
Answer: Tell her that you have played games in arcades before
Reward: Her wearing sunglasses and a t-shirt in an arcade, trying to be incognito
Prompt: She will then lament about all of the attention that she gets as a female pro gamer
Answer: Ask her if the pros outweigh the cons
Reward: A selfie wearing a bra in her bedroom
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “I was expecting more from a ‘world champion’.”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “Prepare to be anally pwned!”
Reward: Her pulling up her sweater, and pulling your hand in to squeeze her breast. (Artwork uses Skin 1 coloring for you, doesn’t change to match customization)
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask about what she should wear
Answer: Suggest for her to wear something tight-fitting to show off her curves
Reward: Her wearing the hoodie
Prompt: She will then start openly wondering about what she is willing to do sexually during this date
Answer: Warn her that she is setting some high expectations regarding this date
Reward: Her showcasing her lower half, while fingering her backdoor
Prompt: She will tell you that she is about to take one more photo, but she doesn’t want it to be leaked
Answer: Tell her that you will keep this away from anyone who asks
Reward: Her lying back, showing off her nude form.
Samara
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask if you would like to get to know more about her
Answer: Muse about how her ‘antisocial’ tendencies are commonplace
Reward: Her giving dual peace signs
Prompt: She starts talking about how she wanted to be more confident.
Answer: Make a joke about how office workers are ‘dead inside’
Reward: Her smiling/laughing
Prompt: She will ask what you want if you could have anything.
Answer: “A fun night with a pretty girl”
Reward: Her crawling up the wall (By the way, she’s a ghost)
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Would it be weird to say I’m a bit of both?”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “Just be yourself.”
Reward: Her sitting on the couch, making a heart with her hands. (Fully clothed)
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She starts talking about her being strong and experienced.
Answer: “Strong girl… So you do crossfit, huh?”
Reward: Her facing the camera, standing fully nude.
Prompt: She directly asks what you are into sexually.
Answer: Tell her you are up for anything.
Reward: Her bent over, showing off her feet.
Prompt: She asks what kind of picture she should take for you next.
Answer: Suggest something spooky, yet sexy.
Reward: Her popping through a painting, still nude.
Skylar
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will admit that she has a fiance.
Answer: Tell her that you will not judge.0
Reward: She will show her engagement ring.
Prompt: She will talk about wanting to find her “knight in shining armor”.
Answer: You don’t have a white horse, but you will try.
Reward: Her sitting in front of her easel.
Prompt: She starts talking about a commission that needs her to show true passion.
Answer: Claim that your middle name is passion.
Reward: Her standing in a sports bra in her studio.
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “I’m sure you have fun here with your fiance.”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “Only if you give him all of the details afterwards.”
Reward: Her pulling up her dress and raising a leg, showing her wet panties.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She states that she hopes you will not make her regret her decision.
Answer: Talk dirty to her.
Reward: A topless shot, with her tweaking her tips.
Prompt: She will wonder if her fiance would let her paint you naked.
Answer: “Only if she was naked”
Reward: Her naked, with some paint on her bust.
Prompt: She will say that she has a photo that you might like.
Answer: “I’ll be sure to share the results… “
Reward: Her lying down, naked.
Taylor
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask if you are 70 year old catfishing her.
Answer: Tell her that you are as young as your profile states, and inquire if there is a story behind her question
Reward: Her giving a peace sign outside of her university.
Prompt: She suggests going to a water park, and asks if you like swimming.
Answer: No to swimming, but you do like the water slide idea.
Reward: Her holding up a swimsuit at a store.
Prompt: She will lament about her heavy workload, and how she needs a distraction.
Answer: Tell her how her idea of them being in swimsuits at a water park should be plenty distracting.
Reward: Her in a halter top, leading a lecture hall.
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Hopefully my shorts stay on.”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “I gotta make sure your top doesn’t fly off.”
Reward: Her top becomes undone, with her holding it up to teasingly show her nipples.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will ask if you will let her ride you.
Answer: “Oh things will heat up if you’ll ride me…”
Reward: Her rubbing her panties with a toy.
Prompt: She will start talking about all of her toys, offering to show you.
Answer: “Sharing is caring”.
Reward: Her nude, “backing up” into a “toy”.
Prompt: She says that she has a gift for you.
Answer: Tell her that you are ready for more toy pics
Reward: Her posing nude underwater.
Frida
First Puzzle
Prompt: She will congratulate you for beating the game.
Answer: Tell her that she is the best girl in the game.
Reward: Her wearing a sports bra and yoga pants.
Prompt: She starts talking about how there might be more games coming ou.
Answer: Ask her what she does other than “shilling for the man”.
Reward: Her wrapping her mouth around a b0ng, wearing a hoodie and panties.
Prompt: She will continue to break the fourth wall, hyping the other girls in-game.
Answer: Ask if this entire date is just a big plug for [Kinky Friday].
Reward: Her in a low-cut top, fanning herself with $1 USD bills.
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “So are we ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ or…” [Gotta love that censor idea: they’re going to ‘heart’ each other]
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “If all of the dates are gems, then you’re a diamond.”
Reward: Her doubled over, naked showing her privates.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She will start talking about how she hopes you’ll “cover her”.
Answer: “You gotta pony up those sweet nudes”
Reward: Her lying down, fingering herself.
Prompt: She tells you how sensitive she is.
Answer: Tell her that she will enjoy you more.
Reward: Her lying back with a vibrator.
Prompt: She will start talking about going after the final pinup.
Answer: Say that she “wouldn’t respect the simp game”
Reward: Her standing up naked, in front of the Kinky Fridays logo.
Julieta
First Puzzle
Prompt: “Do you have a waifu?” [preceded by a ‘healthy ADDITION’ typo]
Answer: “I don’t really fall too much into that crowd.”
Reward: Her in a definitely-not Sailor Moon cosplay.
Prompt: She continues to ask if you know anything about cosplaying.
Answer: “I really don’t have any ideas on it.”
Reward: Her in a low-cut top, holding up parts of her WIP ‘Betroid’ cosplay.
Prompt: She starts talking about how not many people are as accepting of the lifestyle.
Answer: Guess that there is a backstory to that line of thought.
Reward: Her on a train in a Harribel cosplay from Bleach. [Thanks, @Satn Jr for the confirmation]
Cute Scene
Answer 1: “Me? How long can YOU hold your breath?”
Answer 2: one option
Answer 3: “I’m suddenly very interested in trying cosplay!”
Reward: An upward shot, with her pulling her leggings up to accentuate her camel toe.
Second Puzzle
Prompt: She mentions how cons sometimes host orgies.
Answer: Follow the line of logic, with respect to characters getting naughty
Reward: Her in a revealing Warhammer 40K cosplay. [Thanks, @Mr Moseby for the reference]
Prompt: She starts thinking about doing something at the aquarium.
Answer: Suggest fellatio, since she can remain clothed
Reward: Her O-face.
Prompt: She’ll talk about a sexy photo shoot that she did, but she insists for you to watch the anime to go with it.
Answer: “That is a small price to pay”.
Reward: A pantyless cosplay of ‘Shimakaze’ from ‘KanColle’.
Thx for reading ❤
Have Fun!
